First I have a question that I'm really curious about- how do teachers spend time writing while their students write if they are supposed to conference with students during the writer's workshop?
A strong teacher presence in the classroom really helps with class management. I see that in my field placement. Also having materials for students to use is important so students feel they can help themselves and be responsible. My mentor teacher teaches the students a lot about using their resources. Students readily get dictionaries and use the word wall. My classroom is low on space because we are in a "learning cottage" but students all stay at their seats. I like Katie's idea about transitions even happening without the teacher but think that might need to be the teacher's responsibility or even use a timer so a student is not distracted by keeping the time. I liked when Katie said "The best way to manage 'distractions' in the writing workshop is to have plenty of 'attractions' for the students as writers." This is true and will help keep students focused during writing workshop. I had never thought about the creativity that various papers will bring, such as shaped paper and stationary or bordered paper.
One aspect of my own classroom that I am excited to create is a reading/writing corner. I have always wanted to create a comfortable area for students will comfortable pillows and chairs for reading and it can be an option for writing too. I have an idea to make it look like a jungle in the amazon. I also plan to have influences from around the world in my classroom, from trips that I have taken and cultures of my students.
I am definitely one of those teachers who like control and will want to be sure everyone is on task. I really like what Katie says about the environment during writer's workshop and forewarning me that it will feel "out of my control." I liked that she reminded me that it is NOT the behavior that is out of control, but the students' different writing decisions. No teacher wants their classroom behavior to be out of control.
I love the idea of getting students to publish regularly. The type of "workshop" I am seeing drives students to "publish" meaning 'turn in your final draft that has been edited by a teacher' by Friday or you finish during recess. I partially think this method is helping because fewer and fewer students have to finish during recess. The problem with this "workshop" is that the students do not get to write about anything. They get some choice, like who to write about for their special person OR during the "how to" week they chose a topic, but they have to use a certain format. We are trying to teach them how to write paragraphs and use details in each paragraph. The students want to write one sentence per paragraph.
I love what Katie thinks about deadlines and giving them to students. I agree that students need to feel a little pressure to get their piece publish. Even as a adult I need a deadline. If a teacher gives me a future assignment with no deadline I am not going to hardly start the assignment until I am given a deadline. And sometimes I wait until close to the deadline on purpose so I feel the pressure to get it done. So I think giving students a calendar with deadlines will be beneficial in the writing workshop.
On another note, I had the opportunity last week to write while my students wrote. The next day I shared my draft with the class and took their comments. I think they liked hearing what I wrote and knowing the value of writing and YES I even write as a teacher. It was good!